Tuesday, November 10, 2009

More Mapping Love

I'm really loving this map.

Mapping in D&D is always one part science and two parts art. The science part is a matter of very consciously putting the PCs in a place where they can manage to get to a wide variety of environments very quickly. Putting them into the equivalent of, say, Medieval France, is likely to bore them sooner or later ("Yay, more woods."), and they're not too likely to deliberately travel down to the Middle-East. This is why Greyhawk and the Forgotten Realms both have inexplicable magic deserts right next to the core campaign areas.

And, of course, there's the art.

Many game masters complain about their lack of mapping skills but when you get down to it, how much do you really need? The famed West Marches campaign was drawn as a simple vector map that was easy to zoom in or out of at will. Blackmoor was apparently based on a redrawn map of Denmark. For a non-gaming example, Robert Jordan's original Wheel of Time world map isn't all that much to look at. I doubt Ed Greenwood's Forgotten Realms maps looked much like the finished product either.

And yet all of these worlds have enjoyed fame and long life. Why is that? Simply put, because each of them had the map as a starting place, a framework on which to build the narrative, not as the end goal. I noted in my previous post that I've been guilty of forgetting that when creating my own maps, resulting in work that is very pretty to look at, but not robust enough for continued adaption in gameplay. My current map project hits a nice middle ground, I think, between inspirational beauty and gaming utilitarianism.

Despite the above, I do have to say that inspirational beauty is an important component to me when making my maps. That's not to say that the map needs to be a frame-worthy work of art, of course. What it does need to do is make the DM wonder, "What's in this little corner over here?" and "I wonder who lives around that lake over there?" It should be a jumping-off point for fleshing out the world even in the middle of play. A simple sketch on graph paper can be every bit as useful as a professional poster map for that--it just has to have enough incidental detail.

Incidental details like odd little woods in the middle of the grasslands, long lakes in the middle of rivers, the odd hill overlooking the great plains, circles of monoliths, cairns, broken towers, etc. should be sprinkled in liberally. They give the PCs landmarks, places to get a better idea of the lay of the land, mysteries to pursue, and otherwise give the world a feeling of verisimilitude. Not every ruin needs to have a dungeon beneath it (though enough should to encourage the player's to look), a five-page history, or even a name. Nor does every hill, though if a random encounter roll turns up goblins, one should consider the possibility that the hill is their lookout. If you come up with names and histories for them all later, wonderful--especially if such development was for the needs of the campaign. If not, they only took a moment to scrawl in anyway.

As long as we can avoid the temptation to barrage the players with six minutes of historical exposition every half-hour, they'll enjoy the detail of a map well made.



  1. Beauty is when you can appreciate yourself. When you love yourself, that's when you're most beautiful.
    Online Shopping Engine
    Price Comparison Engine
    Best Price Online Shopping Engine

  2. Kullu Manali is the best circuit of Himachal Tourism. It offers wide range of activities and different places to explore from. Manali offers endless excitement and thrill for the explorers. Kullu Manali Package is an amazing gift an individual can give to himself and his/her loved ones.

  3. Looking for Women's Fashion Items? Get the best Prices, 100% Original Products
    FNStylez is offering a wide selection of Lawn up to 25% off,FNStylez including discounts from popular brands such as charizma lawn. To determine the price discount, click on the charizma lawn collection 2019 . There are limited quantities, so make sure to explore all the options.
    This charizma lawn collection 2019 is designed to keep you looking cute, damp environments.

    From the most papular dresses to party tops and blouses etc, that follow the latest pakistani fashion trends of the season: balloon sleeves, bows in collar or cuffs and printed designs.

    Embroidered Lawn Collection 2019 Sale is on your choice branded Summer lawn suits & lawn. Unstiched Printed Lawn Suit For Women - Red Chundri... By adding latest fashion accessories at the time of stitching.

    Embroidered lawn dresses are very famous among women for they serve as a great way to portray style and elegance in a weather that makes it impossible to online shopping in lahore.